Every time I go get my hair cut, the lady who cuts my hair talks about how much she loves the Island’s Fish Grill out near the beach. She always goes for dinner and says the prices are high, but she suggested my wife and I try lunch since it’s a much better deal. Well, today we decided to give it a try since we haven’t tried a new place in a while.
Let me just start out by saying, eating at Island’s Fish Grill has been one of worst experiences I’ve had since moving to the Melbourne area. Not only are the prices extremely high, even for lunch, but the service was so terrible that my wife and I wondered if the waiter (the only one they had working) just didn’t like us. Let me explain.
We arrived about 30 minutes before lunch ended to the small restaurant and were seated amongst 3 other couples who already had their food. We put in our drink orders and looked at the menu; they have a small lunch menu totaling around 8 to 10 items. About 15 minutes later, we placed our lunch order. We only had an hour and a half to eat, so we decided to keep the order simple. We ordered the chicken Caesar wrap with fries ($10.50 which was the special) and the local snapper sandwich with the soup of the day, Manhattan clam chowder ($11.00), prepared with jerk seasoning (+$1.50). We also got water and a Sprite ($2.50). We waited for 40 minutes to get our food during which about 4 more couples came into the restaurant, had their drinks filled, re-filled, and even got their food. When our food finally did come, we washed it down by chewing on the ice in our glasses because we didn’t get to talk to our waiter again until we got our check. I could have sworn my sandwich was supposed to be ~$2 less but by the time we were able to leave it wasn’t worth debating; also my usual patience was already worn far too thin.
I could go into my thoughts on the meals (I did like the fish) but I’m not going to give anyone reading this review any insight to the quality of their food; it’s the least this place deserves. The only thing I can say is unless you like waiting long amounts of time for food that comes with poor service and a ~$30 tab for a couple sandwiches, then Island’s Fish Grill is not for you. You pay to be eat on a road near the beach and for the potential to eat what the local fisherman provide. Bonefish Willy’s is a much better alternative with a great view, food that is just as fresh, and a bigger menu. Maybe one day when I’m really smug and realize I’m better than everyone else I’ll go back.
Island’s Fish Grill is located at 111 5th Avenue, Indialantic, FL 32903.